Gain valuable insights from Carl LeClerq, Technical Lead, Regulatory & Compliance at Dynamic Risk, as he shares industry-leading practice on the review of programs and procedures for pipeline operational excellence.
Why Are Programs and Procedures Necessary for the Successful Operation of an Operator’s System?
A pipeline management system provides a structured framework to manage risk throughout the pipeline lifecycle. This management system documents the objectives, performance requirements, and proper sequence of programs and procedures to be managed, scheduled, tracked, documented, communicated, and reported. For pipeline operators of all sizes, system configurations, and product types, having well-defined programs and procedures in place and regularly reviewed is crucial for several reasons:
- Risk Management: Programs and procedures help identify, assess, and mitigate risks associated with pipeline operations. Utilizing such practices allows operators to maintain a safe and reliable pipeline system. Overarching programs, such as Safety and Loss Management Systems (SLMS) described by API 1173 or pipeline Integrity Management Programs (IMPs) outlined in API 1160 and ASME B31.8S help improve the safety of a system by laying out a framework for an operator to identify and analyze potential precursor events that can result in pipeline incidents, examine the likelihood and potential severity of such incidents, and provide a structured method for selecting and implementing risk reduction activities.
- Regulatory Compliance: All pipeline operators regulated underU.S. regulations 49 CFR Part 192/195 or subject to the requirements of Canadian standard CSA Z662 are required to develop and maintain, through periodic review, program and process level documents – including SLMS/IMPs and Operations & Maintenance (O&M) procedures.
- Operational Efficiency: Clear procedures streamline operations, reduce downtime, and enhance the overall operational efficiency of the pipeline system.
- Continuous Improvement: A structured review approach, such as the “Plan, Do, Check, Act” (PDCA) cycle, ensures continuous improvement in pipeline operations and safety.

Figure 1: Plan-Do-Check-Act (PCDA) Cycle [Source: API 1173-2020]
What Are the Different Levels of Review Available for Programs and Procedures?
Program and procedure reviews can be broken up into three (3) distinct levels that follow the elements of the PDCA cycle. Each review type may be performed at different frequencies based on an operator’s needs and regulatory requirements. Results from these reviews are then used to continuously improve the programs/procedures for the full lifecycle of the assets. These three (3) levels of review and the application of their results are described as follows:
- Level 1: Regulatory Compliance / Industry Standards Alignment (PLAN)
This level of review focuses on verifying that all required elements of an operator’s programs/procedures are in place and align with the latest applicable regulations and/or industry-leading practices. A successful ‘Level 1 Review may confirm the compliance of the reviewed documents or may identify gaps or improvements to the operator’s programs/procedure, allowing for corrective action strategies to be developed and improvements implemented.
- Level 2: Implementation Review (DO/CHECK)
An implementation review acts as an audit of the operator’s program/procedures, verifying that all stated activities and records are being completed and the overall program objectives are being met and applied across the company as required. Verification is completed through a review of program/procedure generated records, the application of reviewer subject matter expertise, interviews with program personnel, and analysis of lagging indicators.
A ‘Level 2 Review’ may be performed internally or by a third party; however, it is important that such a review be performed by an independent party not directly responsible or accountable for the program’s implementation. An independent audit allows for objectivity and impartiality to be maintained and for some regulatory jurisdictions may even be a requirement of the audit process.
A successful “Level 2 Review’ may confirm that all activities and records are being implemented in accordance with the stated conditions within the program/procedures or it may identify gaps in records, non-compliance with required activities, or a general failure to meet stated objectives. Corrective action plans may be developed to address any identified gaps and improvements implemented.
- Level 3: Effectiveness Review (CHECK)
A ‘Level 3 Review’ focuses on the effectiveness of a program in meeting its stated objectives or goals and examines trends in key performance indicators (KPIs) tracked by the program. This review evaluates which elements meet, exceed, or fall short of target values. Continuous trending of KPIs and the regular review of a program’s effectiveness allows operators to identify those elements (e.g., processes, mitigative measures) that provide a positive impact to specific asset threats and/or overall system integrity and operational efficiency.
- Continuous Improvement (ACT)
Each of these review levels may result in the identification of gaps or improvements to the programs/procedures. Operators can use these results to establish corrective action plans, identifying corrective and preventative measures that may improve the performance of their programs or the execution of their procedures. Subsequent reviews would then incorporate these corrective actions and evaluate their effectiveness, thus bringing the PDCA cycle full circle.
When and How Does an Operator Perform Such Reviews and How Are These Tracked?
Operators may perform reviews of their programs and procedures at various frequencies, dependent on the needs of that program/procedure. Industry-leading standards on the management of programs (e.g., API 1160, ASME B31.8S, etc.)note that periodic reviews of programs be at frequencies that will allow the operator to properly evaluate the effectiveness of such programs. API 1173 and many regulators go a step further and prescribe an annual review frequency for these programs, in line with an operator’s annual threat and risk assessment, and with the distinct purpose of incorporating results from these assessments into the program reviews to better establish their effectiveness.
Additional reviews of the programs/procedures may be warranted beyond the established frequency based on changes made to regulatory codes, updates to utilized industry standards, modifications to covered assets, or any other changes that an operator may deem to have a significant impact to the programs/procedures.
An operator may choose to align their program and procedure reviews with an annual review, or they may choose to offset them, with annual program reviews and an extended 2–3-year period for procedure reviews. An operator may choose to conduct “Level 1” and “Level 3” reviews on an annual basis to capture changes to code and industry standards and evaluate the effectiveness of their programs/procedures in managing the risks to their system. They may then choose to conduct independent internal or external audits on a biennial basis (i.e., every two years) or prior to a scheduled regulatory audit. An example review schedule is shown in Table 1. Operators should consider the needs of their programs/procedures and the requirements of regulations in which their assets are subject to when determining the review level and frequencies for their programs/procedures.
Table 1: Example Program & Procedure Review Schedule
| Document Type | Review Level | Review Frequency |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The results of each review should be recorded by the operator in a manner appropriate to their organizational and regulatory needs. This may be in the form of a summary report, a concordance table, or other formats deemed appropriate by the operator or regulator. All gaps or improvements from a review should also be captured in a corrective action plan. Actions taken to close any gaps, or any improvements made to the programs/procedures should trigger an operators Management of Change (MOC) process, with the results from the review, the changes made to the programs/procedures, and the impacts of these changes to stakeholders documented and communicated to these stakeholders.
Dynamic Risk Program and Procedure Review Services
By adopting a structured, three (3) level review approach that follows the PDCA cycle, and adhering to industry-leading practices and regulatory requirements, operators can achieve continuous improvement and maintain compliance. Dynamic Risk supports operators in these efforts by providing expertise in each of the three review levels and can assist operators in creating a tailored review structure that meets their organizational needs.
Dynamic Risk has experience with supporting operators of all sizes, system configurations, and product types with these reviews. Dynamic Risk has conducted each of the three (3) review levels for our clients, with the scope of the document review ranging from a single program or procedure, all the way to organizational-wide SLMS program suites and their supporting documents (i.e., sub-programs, procedures, works instructions, forms).
For more information on how Dynamic Risk can assist your organization with program and procedure management and reviews, please visit our website or contact us directly.
About the Author:

Carl LeClerq, Technical Lead, Regulatory & Compliance
Carl currently serves as an Integrity Engineer at Dynamic Risk Assessment Systems, Inc., in the role of Team Lead, Regulatory and Compliance. In this role, he analyzes client records, databases, and assessments to identify improvement opportunities within the integrity management process. This includes threat identification, risk models, baseline assessment plans, reassessment schedules, and preventative and mitigative measures. Carl employs his knowledge of PHMSA and CER regulations to develop robust enhancement strategies for new or existing integrity management programs. He also assists in creating plans and procedures for all levels of pipeline integrity management, including integrity management programs, threat response guidance documents, standard operating procedures, and work instructions.